Spencer Shay/Jerry Trainor pages nominated for deletion

This post is locked.

3cooldog92·10/4/2013 in Article changes

I'm nominating the Spencer Shay and Jerry Trainor for deletion as the one source we have doesn't provide the kind of clear confirmation we need to justify having pages for them. All this tweet proves is that Jerry was on set that day. Note Dan said "special guest", not "guest star". It's possible Jerry was in an episode, but this is not the clear confirmation we need. Also, the promos episode he was supposedly in, 113 (now known to be #SecretSafe) doesn't have him in them. This board applies to both the Jerry and Spencer pages since the decision will apply to both.

As of right now the pages don't belong here. If that changes in the future due to proof that Jerry/Spencer will be on the show we can always restore the pages. Also, if this goes through I'll be protecting those pages from recreation.

(Edited by 3cooldog92)

ArianaGrandeForever·10/4/2013

Delete — I agree. You said everything needed to say, and I don't think I can say any more.

(Edited by ArianaGrandeForever)

Jeminali·10/4/2013

Delete — Agree, because the source does't confirm he wil guest star in an episode.

(Edited by Jeminali)

BelgiumHelper·10/4/2013

Oppose —

The pages are saying that he is a possible guest star. So far, only a few out of forty episodes have reached the screen. Who knows for sure that he wil not appear? He can also appear in a possible next season?

(Jerry Trainor was mentioned and seen in a picture during the credits of #TextingCompetition)

(Edited by BelgiumHelper)

3cooldog92·10/4/2013

BelgiumHelper wrote:

Oppose —

(Jerry Trainor was mentioned and seen in a picture during the credits of #TextingCompetition)

There are a lot of possible guest stars that we don't have pages for. Nathan Kress comes to mind here. The source doesn't make it clear that he'll be on.

Also, cast pages should only exist if we know for sure they will appear, not just because we're not 100% sure they won't appear. If we had a page for every actor/actress that might appear we'd have a pagefor all the iCarly and Victorious cast members. Again, if we find out that Jerry will appear after we delete the page undeleting the page would be a simple matter. We just don't have the kind of proof we need right now.

(Edited by 3cooldog92)

BelgiumHelper·10/4/2013

Support — I agree with you about the Spencer Shay page. It is not sure if he will appear and we can't have a page for all the possible guest characters.

BUT

Oppose — I do not agree with you on the Jerry Trainor page. Since he was SEEN AND MENTIONED in one episode (#TextingCompetition). Also, since this wikia is about all things Sam and Cat, I think he should be included.

(Edited by BelgiumHelper)

Teleram·10/5/2013

Support — for the Spencer page

(Edited by Teleram)

3cooldog92·10/6/2013

Since there appears to be a consensus in favor of deletion I will go ahead and delete the articles and protect them from recreation. If we get better proof I'll restore them.

(Edited by 3cooldog92)